Replay an Awesome Game? Or Play a New Game?

  (Edited: )

Which do you tend to go for?

When you find yourself itching to play a game, do you default think of a game that you love, that you know is amazing, and think "Hey I want to play that again," or do you default think of or seek out a game you've never played before?

I suppose I do a little bit of both, but on the whole, I lean towards replaying awesome games because I know I will enjoy the experience, and I know what to expect from the experience. It's a massive thrill to play a new game for the first time and discover that it is amazing, but I also always feel like I'm taking a risk. What if it isn't any good? Will I feel like I have wasted my time?

Which do you lean towards? Why?