Quite the necro

As I mentioned in my own post, I don't have any competitive experience with brood war, so obviously, yes, I was talking as someone who doesn't have extensive brood war experience.

However, everything you said agrees with what I said, so I don't know where your issue is. We seem to agree that mechanical ability was far more important in brood war than in sc2, (your examples of winning with 1 zealot, or being ahead 2 seconds in, etc.).

We have different preferences clearly, but we seem to agree on what the differences are. If I'm missing something on this point, please correct me.